The Hidden Risks of Beneficiary Designations in Florida (And How to Fix Them)

Most of us want the same thing from an estate plan: when we pass away, our loved ones receive what we leave them, with as little cost and delay as possible. So it makes sense that many people simply name their children or other family members as beneficiaries on their bank accounts, life insurance, and investments and call it a day.

There is a lot to like about that approach. But beneficiary designations also have some drawbacks that catch families off guard. Let's walk through the benefits, the risks, and what you can do about them.

Why People Love Beneficiary Designations

In Florida, probate can be expensive and slow. Depending on the estate, it can take several months and sometimes much longer to finish. Assets that go through probate are open to claims from creditors, and once a probate case is opened, it becomes easier for someone to contest your will.

Beneficiary designations sidestep much of that. They are simple, they cost nothing to put in place, and assets that pass directly to a named beneficiary generally skip probate. In many cases, those assets also receive protection from your creditors. If you have a will and no interest in setting up a trust, naming beneficiaries on your accounts is a smart move, and far better than leaving everything to probate.

That said, a comprehensive estate plan should weigh the risks too.

Risk #1: Your Beneficiary Passes Away Before You Do

This is the most obvious risk. Ideally, if a beneficiary dies, you would contact each financial institution and name someone new. But life does not always cooperate. You might be grieving and simply never get back to it. Or, by that point, you might be dealing with dementia or another condition that leaves you without the legal capacity to make changes.

If your beneficiary has passed away and no one else is named, that account may have to go through probate after all, which is the very thing you were trying to avoid.

Florida does have a safeguard for this situation. If you have a durable power of attorney, your agent may be able to update beneficiary designations for you, but only if the document gives that specific authority and you initialed it when you signed. Many older power of attorney forms leave this out, so it is worth checking yours.

Risk #2: The Split Doesn't Match What You Wanted

Say you have four children, each named as a 25 percent beneficiary, and one of them passes away before you do. Every financial institution has its own rules, but the most common result is that the deceased child's share gets divided among the three surviving siblings.

Maybe that is what you would have wanted. Or maybe you would have preferred that share go to your grandchildren. When the outcome is different from what you intended, your family pays the price. Naming contingent beneficiaries helps reduce this risk, but it does not remove the next one.

Risk #3: A Lump-Sum Inheritance Can Cost Someone Their Benefits

This is the risk we talk about most with our clients at Elder Needs Law. Apart from something like an IRA, most accounts with a beneficiary listed (bank accounts, life insurance, brokerage and investment accounts) pay out directly to the beneficiary, usually in one lump sum.

That is great from a probate standpoint. But if your beneficiary receives Medicaid, SSI, certain VA benefits, or another need-based government program, an outright inheritance can push them over the asset limit and cause them to lose their benefits. In Florida, those limits are low. For many programs, an individual can hold only $2,000 in countable assets.

You might be thinking, "My beneficiaries are all healthy, so this doesn't apply to us." But none of us can predict the future. An accident or illness can leave anyone needing long-term care, and many families rely on Medicaid to help cover those costs. If a beneficiary is receiving those benefits on the day you pass away, a direct inheritance could cost them their coverage right when they need it most.

How to Protect Your Loved Ones

The good news is that each of these risks can be addressed with thoughtful planning:

• Review your designations regularly. Check them after any major life event, such as a death, birth, marriage, or divorce.
• Name contingent beneficiaries. This gives your accounts a backup plan.
• Check your power of attorney. Make sure it gives your agent specific authority over beneficiary designations, in case you ever cannot make changes yourself.
• Consider naming a trust as your beneficiary. A trust can control how and when money is paid out, spell out what happens if a beneficiary passes away first, and, with a properly drafted supplemental needs trust, allow a beneficiary to receive an inheritance without losing eligibility for Medicaid or SSI.

Beneficiary designations work best as one piece of a larger plan, not as the whole plan.

Talk With a Florida Estate Planning and Elder Law Attorney

If you have beneficiary designations in place and you are not sure how they fit with the rest of your plan, we can help. At Elder Needs Law, we work with Florida families on estate planning, Medicaid planning, and protecting loved ones who rely on government benefits. We will look at your accounts, your documents, and your family situation, and show you where changes would make the biggest difference.

Visit us at elderneedslaw.com or medicaidplanninglawyer.com to schedule a consultation.

Want More Information on Medicaid and Long-Term Care Costs?

Our book covers how Medicaid can help with some of your long-term care expenses and what steps Florida families can take to protect their assets. You can find it on Amazon: https://www.amazon.com/Medicaid-some-your-long-term-expenses/dp/1513634712

This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Every family's situation is different, so please talk with a Florida attorney about your specific circumstances.

‍