Does Your Mom Need a Guardianship After an Alzheimer's or Dementia Diagnosis in Florida?

Does Your Mom Need a Guardianship After an Alzheimer's or Dementia Diagnosis in Florida?
Medicaid Planning
Jason Neufeld
November 16, 2026

If your mom was just diagnosed with Alzheimer's disease or dementia, you've probably heard the word "guardianship" from a friend, a doctor's office, or a late-night internet search. It's a scary word, and families often assume it's the next step. Here's the good news: in most cases, it isn't.

A diagnosis does not automatically mean a Florida court has to step in. Let's walk through why, and what you can do right now to protect your mom and keep the decisions in your family's hands.

A Diagnosis Is Not the Same as Incapacity

Many families hear the words "Alzheimer's" or "dementia" and assume a judge needs to get involved right away. But a diagnosis is only part of the picture. What matters legally is whether your loved one can still make informed decisions about her money, her health care, and her daily life.

Dementia is a spectrum, and where your mom falls on it makes all the difference:

Early stage: She may be mostly independent, with some mild memory loss. She can still follow information, share her wishes, and sign legal documents.

Middle stage: Confusion and forgetfulness increase, and she needs daily support. Her ability to sign documents may be in question and can vary from one day to the next.

Late stage: She may not be able to communicate, and she may not recognize the faces of the people closest to her.

Because of this, two people with the same diagnosis can be in very different legal positions. One may be fully able to sign a power of attorney this week. Another may not be.

What Can Your Mom Still Sign?

In the early stages, many people can still sign the documents that let trusted family members step in later. In Florida, these commonly include:

Durable power of attorney: Lets someone you trust handle financial matters, such as paying bills, managing accounts, and dealing with property, if your mom can't. Florida requires it to be signed in front of two witnesses and a notary. Also, Florida no longer recognizes "springing" powers of attorney that only take effect after incapacity, so the document should be effective when signed.

Designation of health care surrogate: Names the person who can make medical decisions for her if she can't make them herself.

Living will: Puts her wishes about end-of-life care in writing, so your family isn't left guessing.

Revocable living trust: Can allow a successor trustee to manage trust assets without court involvement.

When these documents are in place and valid, guardianship usually isn't needed at all.

When Guardianship Becomes Necessary

Guardianship is a court process under Chapter 744 of the Florida Statutes. A Florida court will consider it when a person can no longer make or communicate informed decisions, and there is no less restrictive alternative available.

That second part matters. Florida courts are expected to look at whether a power of attorney, health care surrogate, or similar tool is already in place before taking away someone's rights. If those documents exist and work, the court generally has no reason to appoint a guardian.

Here's where guardianship becomes the only option. Say your mom has reached the point where she can't grasp what a legal document means, nobody holds a power of attorney, and an important financial or medical decision has to be made. She can't validly sign anything, and no one has authority to act. At that point, a court proceeding is the only way forward.

What does that look like? A petition is filed to determine incapacity, and a committee of examiners evaluates your mom. If the court finds she is incapacitated, it can remove some or all of her legal rights and appoint a guardian. The guardian then answers to the court, which means filing reports and following court rules. It can also be costly, slow, and hard on everyone involved, especially your mom, who loses a say in her own life.

Timing Matters More Than Anything

This is the part we most want families to hear. Too many wait until a crisis hits, like a fall, a hospital stay, or a bank refusing to talk to a family member, before they call an attorney. By then, your mom may no longer have the capacity to sign the very documents that would have kept you out of court.

That's why we encourage families to get these documents in place as early as possible after a diagnosis. Even better, do it well before any diagnosis. Think about it this way: even a healthy 60-year-old who runs marathons should recognize that this level of independence may not last forever. Signing these documents while you're healthy is one of the kindest things you can do for the people who love you.

The goal is simple. Avoid guardianship. Keep your loved one protected. And let you, or better yet, your mom herself, decide who helps with her affairs, rather than a judge who has never met your family.

What to Do Right Now

If your mom was just diagnosed, here are a few practical steps:

  1. Gather any existing documents, such as a power of attorney, health care surrogate designation, will, or trust.
  2. Don't wait for a bad day to happen first. Capacity can change, and a good day is a good day to act.
  3. Talk with an elder law attorney about whether your mom can still sign, and which documents make the most sense for her situation.
  4. Look ahead to long-term care costs. Dementia care can be expensive, and Medicaid planning is often part of the conversation.

On that last point, Jason Neufeld has written a book on this topic, Medicaid and some of your long-term care expenses, available on Amazon: https://www.amazon.com/Medicaid-some-your-long-term-expenses/dp/1513634712

Talk With Elder Needs Law

Elder Needs Law serves families throughout the entire state of Florida. If you or your loved one has recently been diagnosed with Alzheimer's disease or dementia, we can sit down with you, look at where things stand, and help you figure out whether guardianship is actually needed or whether a less restrictive alternative will do the job.

Visit elderneedslaw.com or medicaidplanninglawyer.com to schedule a consultation.

Websites:
https://elderneedslaw.com
https://medicaidplanninglawyer.com/

If you found this helpful, please share it with a friend or family member who might be facing the same question. Our goal is to get good information into the hands of Floridians everywhere.

‍

Jason Neufeld

Jason Neufeld is a Board-Certified Elder Law Attorney and the Managing Partner of Elder Needs Law, PLLC, a Florida Medicaid Planning, Estate Planning, Special Needs Planning, Probate and Elder Law Firm.

Jason is an award-winning Elder Law attorney and leader among Medicaid Planning and Estate Planning attorneys (he is on the Board of Directors for the Academy of Florida Elder Law Attorneys and Co-Chairs the Broward County Bar Association Elder Law Section). The firm serves the entire State of Florida remotely or at any of our physical locations. Interested in additional free or low-cost information. Check out Jason's Book or free educational videos

Related Post

Text Us

To contact us, please text this number:

305-363-1955

By texting us you authorize Elder Needs Law, PLLC to send text messages and marketing content to the mobile number provided. Consent is not a condition of purchase. Message & data rates apply. Message frequency may vary. Text HELP for support or more information. Text STOP to opt out at any time.

Privacy Policy Terms of Use