;

Should You Handle Your Medicaid Renewal Yourself? Here's What You Need to Know

Should You Handle Your Medicaid Renewal Yourself? Here's What You Need to Know
Medicaid Planning
Jason Neufeld
November 26, 2025

You've made it through the initial Medicaid application process—congratulations! That's genuinely a huge accomplishment. But now comes the annual renewal, and you're probably wondering: should I handle this myself or pay someone to do it?

It's a fair question. Nobody wants to spend money unnecessarily, and I'm always honest with my clients about this. You can handle your Medicaid renewal on your own. It doesn't require a law degree. The paperwork is involved, sure, but it's not rocket science.

So why am I writing this article? Because I want you to make an informed decision about what's actually at stake.

The Real Cost of a Small Mistake

Let me tell you about a recent situation with one of our clients. She was sharp—really intelligent, organized, and capable. She wanted to save some money, so she decided to handle her mother's renewal herself. We totally understood and wished her well.

A few weeks later, she came back to us in a panic. The renewal had been denied. She'd put information in the wrong section of the forms. The state claimed they sent a notice asking for additional information. She claimed she never received it.

Here's the thing: I wasn't involved in that renewal process, so I can't tell you who was right and who was wrong. But I can tell you this—it doesn't really matter. What matters is that her mother's Medicaid benefits were now in jeopardy over what was likely a simple, fixable error.

Why Medicaid Renewals Get Denied in Florida

Florida's Medicaid system is complex, and the Department of Children and Families (DCF) handles an enormous volume of applications and renewals with limited resources. This creates several common problems:

The state makes mistakes too. They're dealing with an underfunded, overworked bureaucracy. Sometimes renewals get denied inappropriately. Sometimes notices get lost. Sometimes information gets misprocessed.

The forms are tricky. While not as complicated as the initial application, the renewal forms still require accurate financial documentation, proper categorization of assets, and careful attention to Florida's specific Medicaid waiver program requirements.

Deadlines are strict. Miss a deadline or fail to respond to a request for information (whether you received it or not), and you could lose your benefits.

Communication is difficult. Try calling DCF with a question. You might be on hold for an hour. Getting through to someone who can actually help you can feel impossible.

What Happens If Your Renewal Gets Denied?

If you're on Florida's Medicaid waiver program or receiving long-term care services through the Institutional Care Program (ICP)—whether you're in a nursing facility, assisted living facility, or receiving care at home—losing your Medicaid benefits is a serious problem.

You're suddenly facing the full cost of care, which in Florida can easily run $4,000 to $8,000 per month or more, depending on your situation. And while you work to get your benefits reinstated, those bills keep coming.

Yes, you can appeal a denial. But appeals take time, and they require you to present your case effectively to the state. This means gathering documentation, writing letters, potentially attending hearings, and knowing which regulations to cite.

What We Do Differently When Handling Renewals

When we handle your annual Medicaid renewal, we're not just filling out forms. We're providing insurance against the kind of problems that can derail your benefits.

We know the system inside and out. We submit these renewals all the time. We know exactly what information goes where, what documentation Florida requires, and how to present everything in a way that moves smoothly through the system.

We catch problems before they become problems. If there's an issue with your renewal—maybe your financial situation has changed, or there's a question about an asset—we spot it early and address it proactively.

We deal with the bureaucracy for you. When something goes wrong (and sometimes things just go wrong), we know how to get to supervisors. We know who to call. We know how to push back when the state makes an error. We speak their language.

We guarantee our work. Unless you've done something inappropriate that you haven't told us about, we're going to get your renewal approved. And if there's a denial, we're going to fight it at no additional cost to you.

The Real Question: What's Your Time Worth?

Yes, we charge a fee to handle renewals. And yes, that costs money. But what's your time worth? What's your peace of mind worth?

Think about what's involved if you handle it yourself:

  • Gathering all the required financial documents
  • Filling out the forms correctly
  • Making copies of everything
  • Submitting everything by the deadline
  • Following up to make sure it was received
  • Responding to any requests for additional information
  • Dealing with any problems that arise

Now think about what your life looks like right now. If you're caring for a loved one who needs long-term care, you're already stretched thin. You have better things to focus on than wrestling with Florida's Medicaid bureaucracy.

Making Your Decision

I respect whatever decision you make. Many people do handle their renewals themselves and everything goes fine. But a percentage of people who go it alone end up with denied renewals, interrupted benefits, and a mess that's much more expensive to clean up than the renewal fee would have been.

This is really about transferring the headache from you to us. We're good at this. It's what we do. We want your Medicaid renewal to be as carefree and worry-free as possible so you can focus on what matters—your family and your loved one's care.

Additional Resources

If you want to learn more about Florida Medicaid planning and how to protect your assets while qualifying for long-term care benefits, I've written a comprehensive book on the subject: "How to Get Medicaid to Pay for Some of Your Long-Term Care Expenses", available on Amazon.

You can also find more information and resources on our websites:

If you're one of our clients and you'd like us to handle your upcoming renewal, just give us a call. If you want to handle it yourself, we genuinely wish you well—just please be careful and thorough.

And if you're not yet a client but you're facing the Medicaid application or renewal process in Florida, we're here to help. The initial application is definitely something I'd recommend having a professional handle, particularly if you need to protect assets or accelerate your eligibility.

Your Medicaid benefits are too important to risk. Whether you choose to work with us or handle it yourself, make sure it's done right.

Jason Neufeld

Jason Neufeld is a Board-Certified Elder Law Attorney and the Managing Partner of Elder Needs Law, PLLC, a Florida Medicaid Planning, Estate Planning, Special Needs Planning, Probate and Elder Law Firm.

Jason is an award-winning Elder Law attorney and leader among Medicaid Planning and Estate Planning attorneys (he is on the Board of Directors for the Academy of Florida Elder Law Attorneys and Co-Chairs the Broward County Bar Association Elder Law Section). The firm serves the entire State of Florida remotely or at any of our physical locations. Interested in additional free or low-cost information. Check out Jason's Book or free educational videos

Related Post